Is soft or hard tonneau cover better? When it comes to choosing between the two, personal preference and specific needs play a crucial role.
We’ll dive into the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed decision.
From affordability to durability, we’ll explore the key factors that can impact your choice.
Is Soft Or Hard Tonneau Cover Better?
Choosing between a soft or hard tonneau cover depends on personal preference and needs.
Soft covers are less expensive and easier to install but offer less security and protection.
Hardcovers are more durable and secure but pricier and harder to install. Consider budget, security, and protection when deciding.
Quick Comparison Table Between Soft and Hard Tonneau Cover
| Feature | Soft Tonneau Cover | Hard Tonneau Cover |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Less expensive | More expensive |
| Weight | Lighter | Heavier |
| Security | Less secure | More secure |
| Durability | Less durable | More durable |
| Weather resistance | Less weather-resistant | More weather-resistant |
| Ease of installation | Easier to install | More difficult to install |
| Access to the truck bed | More access to the truck bed | Less access to the truck bed |
| Appearance | More stylish | Less stylish |
Details Comparison Between Soft and Hard Tonneau Cover
Price
Soft tonneau covers cost less due to lighter materials and easier manufacturing.
Prices range from $200 to $1,000. On the other hand, hard tonneau covers cost between $500 and $2,000.
Verdict: If you’re on a budget, a soft tonneau cover is a good choice.
Weight
Soft tonneau covers are lighter since they lack a rigid frame. They weigh 20 to 50 pounds, while hard tonneau covers weigh 50 to 100 pounds.
Verdict: For a lightweight, easy-to-install option, go for a soft tonneau cover.
Security
Hard tonneau covers are more secure with their harder materials and rigid frame. They’re difficult to break into and less prone to theft compared to soft ones.
Verdict: If you need superior cargo protection against theft, choose a hard tonneau cover.
Durability
Hard tonneau covers are sturdier, thanks to their harder materials and rigid frame. They withstand rain, snow, wind, and hail, which can damage soft tonneau covers.
Verdict: For durability against the elements and rough use, a hard tonneau cover is ideal.
Weather Resistance
Hard tonneau covers offer better weather resistance due to their sturdier materials and rigid frame.
They keep your cargo dry during rain and snow, while soft tonneau covers may allow water in.
Verdict: A hard tonneau cover effectively protects cargo from the elements.
Ease of Installation
Soft tonneau covers are easier to install since they’re made of lighter materials and lack a rigid frame.
Installation takes a few hours, while hard tonneau covers may require a day or more.
Verdict: If you prefer an easier installation process, go for a soft tonneau cover.
Access to the Truck Bed
Soft tonneau covers allow more access to the truck bed. They can be rolled up or folded away, while hard tonneau covers require opening or unlocking.
Verdict: If easy access to the truck bed is important to you, choose a soft tonneau cover.
Appearance
Hard tonneau covers are generally considered more stylish with their harder materials and finished look. Soft tonneau covers may appear flimsier and unfinished.
Verdict: For a stylish tonneau cover that complements your truck’s look, opt for a hard one.
Overall Verdict
The best tonneau cover depends on your needs and preferences.
A soft tonneau cover is lightweight, affordable, and easy to install. A hard tonneau cover offers greater security, durability, and weather resistance.
Pros and cons of each type of tonneau cover
Soft Tonneau Cover
Pros:
- Affordable: Soft tonneau covers are generally less expensive than hard tonneau covers.
- Lightweight: Soft tonneau covers are lighter than hard tonneau covers, making them easier to install and remove.
- Easy to install: Soft tonneau covers are generally easier to install than hard tonneau covers.
- More access to truck bed: Soft tonneau covers can be rolled up or folded out of the way when you need access to your truck bed.
- Versatile: Soft tonneau covers are available in a variety of styles and materials, so you can find one that fits your needs and budget.
Cons:
- Less secure: Soft tonneau covers are less secure than hard ones, as they are easier to break into.
- Less durable: Soft tonneau covers are less durable than hard tonneau covers, and they may not be able to withstand the elements as well.
- Not as stylish: Soft tonneau covers are not as stylish as hard tonneau covers, and they may not complement the look of your truck as well.
Hard Tonneau Cover
Pros:
- More secure: Hard tonneau covers are more secure than soft ones, as they are more difficult to break into.
- More durable: Hard tonneau covers are more durable than soft tonneau covers, and they can withstand the elements better.
- More stylish: Hard tonneau covers are more stylish than soft ones, and they can complement the look of your truck better.
Cons:
- More expensive: Hard tonneau covers are generally more expensive than soft tonneau covers.
- Heavier: Hard tonneau covers are heavier than soft ones, making them more difficult to install and remove.
- Less access to the truck bed: Hard tonneau covers must be opened or unlocked to access the truck bed, which can be inconvenient.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Soft and Hard Tonneau Covers
Security
Ensuring the security of your cargo is crucial, especially if you frequently transport valuable items or equipment in your truck bed.
Hard tonneau covers provide a higher level of security as they are typically made from sturdy materials like fiberglass or aluminum.
These covers are more difficult to break into than soft covers, usually made from vinyl or canvas. If security is your top priority, a hard tonneau cover might be better.
Durability
You want a tonneau cover that can withstand all weather and daily use. Hardcovers are generally more durable and resistant to wear and tear.
They are better equipped to handle heavy snow loads, harsh UV rays, and strong winds.
Soft covers, on the other hand, may be susceptible to fading, tearing, or stretching over time.
If you live in an area with extreme weather conditions or if you frequently transport heavy cargo, a hard tonneau cover may be the more durable option.
Installation and Accessibility
Installation and access to your vehicle bed might dramatically affect your tonneau cover experience.
Soft covers are typically easier to install and remove, as they often use a clamp or Velcro system.
They offer more flexibility, allowing you to roll or fold them for full bed access.
Hardcovers, however, often require professional installation and may be more cumbersome to remove.
However, some hardcovers have innovative features like folding panels or hydraulic lifts, providing convenient access to your truck bed.
Style and Appearance
The aesthetic appeal of your tonneau cover can enhance the overall look of your truck.
Soft covers have a sleek and streamlined appearance that complements most truck models.
They offer a more integrated and low-profile look when installed. On the other hand, hardcovers can provide a more rugged and structured appearance.
They may come in various finishes, such as glossy or matte, allowing you to match your truck’s style.
Consider the visual impact you desire for your truck and choose a tonneau cover accordingly.
Cost
Cost is often a significant factor in any purchasing decision. Soft tonneau covers generally have a lower upfront cost compared to hardcovers.
A soft cover might be the more affordable option if you’re on a tight budget.
However, it’s important to remember that soft covers may require more frequent replacement or maintenance.
Hard tonneau coverings are initially more expensive, but their durability and resale value can save money.
Do Soft Tonneau Covers Stretch More than Hard Tonneau Covers?
Tonneau cover stretching explained: Soft tonneau covers have greater flexibility and elasticity compared to hard tonneau covers, allowing them to stretch more. This flexibility enables soft covers to conform closely to the truck bed, providing a snug fit. Hard covers, on the other hand, are rigid and do not stretch as much. The degree of stretching ultimately depends on the materials used in the tonneau cover construction.
FAQs
Can A Hard Tonneau Cover Be Removed Easily?
Hard tonneau covers are more permanent installations compared to soft covers.
While some hard covers can be removed, it typically requires tools and more effort compared to soft covers.
Do Soft Tonneau Covers Provide Good Security?
Soft tonneau covers offer a certain level of security by concealing your cargo from view.
However, they are not as secure as hardcovers since they can be easily cut open, making them less effective in preventing theft.
Are Soft Tonneau Covers Easier To Maintain?
Soft tonneau covers are generally easier to maintain. They can be cleaned with mild soap and water, and some models can be machine-washed.
They also tend to be less prone to scratches and dents than hardcovers.
final words
Choosing between a soft or hard tonneau cover rests on your personal preferences and requirements.
Soft covers offer affordability and easy installation, while hardcovers provide superior security and durability.
Consider your budget, desired level of security, and protection for your truck bed. Whether you prioritize versatility or a tough shield, make an informed choice that suits your needs.
